So I recently acquired
Hearthside Cooking by Nancy Carter Crump. It is a book that I have had my eye on for a while, and would you know that WAHLAH it was on my shelf at work (a perk of the system I must admit). I perused the pages for days soaking in what Crump has to say; and as one who is constantly trying to find better, more accurate ways to do things, this was a wealthy of knowledge and I highly recommend it to anyone.
Back to the food- where this particular recipe comes from I am not too sure. Crump credits Eliza Leslie with the recipie for Indian Pound Cake on pg. 202. I have found at least two references to such a cake- in
Seventy-five receipts for pastry, cakes, and sweetmeats, 1836, under "Indian batter cakes". Also found in
Directions for Cookery, in Its Various Branches, 1844.
 |
| Recipe as seen in Directions for Cookery, 1844. |
The cake does have a simple list of ingredients; flour, cornmeal, sugar, butter, eggs, etc. This is a great option for making a cake when you don't have a chance to run to the store, most of these items are pantry staples. I warn you, make sure you have enough time to put this cake together (about 30 minutes). I try to do everything manually- not using electric mixers, etc.- so that I can get more accurate time if it is something I want to try in a camp setting. This cake also took about 4 bowls to mix- but I am a messy baker!
Start by combining your dry ingredients. The recipe suggest 2 tsp of grated nutmeg, I tend to think it is a bit overpowering, so I only used about half of a nutmeg.
Beating the eggs "until foamy" will take some time. You can use an electric mixer if making this at home- if not, pull out your trusty whisk and get to it....then when you get tired- make your husband whisk as well! Remember the eggs are the leavening for this recipe so this is a vital step.
 |
| Check out his lovely Regency Sideburns! |
When those eggs are nice and foamy- start creaming your butter, adding a little sugar at a time until well incorporated, beat until nice and fluffy.
Now, there are three different elements to the cake- dry ingredients, eggs, and sugar/butter. Time to combine these. Add about one third of the dry mix to the butter, incorporate well, then add about one third of the eggs, combine well- continued until well mixed. This will be a very thick batter, more like a dough, but don't worry!
Put batter into a well buttered tube pan-
 |
| Cake batter in my great-grandmothers pan. |
Place in a 325* oven- this cake will take about a hour and half to bake. During this time, sit, rest your arms, this has been a workout of a cake!
Check your cake- when a knife comes out clean, it is ready. Turn it out of the pan, and TA-DA...CAKE! I am amazed every time my cake falls right out of that pan perfectly.
This cake turns out to have a great flavor! It tastes like very sweet corn-bread. It is a nice cake when it is fresh out of the oven. But, as Eliza Leslie suggests, its does become very dry and hard and almost like sawdust if left sitting out. I made this particular cake for an event I was attending, and forgot it :(, and when we got home it was too dry to eat.
I must say that I think this has been my most successful cake to date, good flavor, not too heavy.
Happy Cooking!!